Lessons from The Bachelor Franchise: Racism and Cancel Culture
What We Can Learn from the Bachelor Franchise, Chris Harrison, systemic racism, and how cancel culture isn't effective…
Understanding Cancel Culture
Cancel culture is withdrawing support for public figures and companies after they have done or said something considered objectionable or offensive. While often well-intentioned, aiming to hold individuals accountable, it can serve as a tool of white supremacy by focusing on punishment rather than systemic change. This approach emphasizes shaming and ostracizing individuals rather than addressing the underlying structures that perpetuate oppression. Rooted in white supremacy, cancel culture upholds the status quo by creating the illusion of progress without challenging the deeper societal issues. It diverts attention from systemic problems and places undue emphasis on individual culpability, thus preventing the kind of collective action needed to dismantle oppressive systems. The Bachelor Franchise and the situation with Chris Harrison provide a clear example of the limitations and ineffectiveness of cancel culture.
Image Description: The image shows a silhouetted hand holding a long-stemmed rose against a vibrant red background. The rose is upright, with the hand gently grasping the stem near the base and the middle. The red background creates a dramatic contrast, highlighting the delicate shape of the rose and the outline of the hand. The overall composition gives a sense of elegance and intensity.
The Racist Roots of The Bachelor Franchise
Since its inception, The Bachelor Franchise has been criticized for its lack of diversity and its perpetuation of racist and oppressive behaviours. For instance, it took 25 seasons for the show to cast its first Black bachelor, Matt James, despite repeated calls for more inclusive representation. Additionally, the franchise has faced backlash for its handling of contestants' racially insensitive actions and for often featuring predominantly white casts and storylines that fail to address or include diverse perspectives.
The Downfall of Chris Harrison
Chris Harrison's departure from The Bachelor came during the rise of the Black Lives Matter movement. His exit was triggered by an interview in which he defended a contestant's attendance at an antebellum-themed party, which many saw as racially insensitive. His comments, seen as dismissive of the concerns about the contestant's actions, led to widespread criticism and, ultimately, his stepping down from his role as host.
Continued Racism Despite Harrison's Exit
Even after Chris Harrison's departure, the franchise has continued to exhibit racially insensitive behaviour, indicating that removing one individual did not resolve the underlying issues. For example, there have been instances where contestants' past racist behaviours were exposed, and the franchise's responses were seen as inadequate. These events highlight a lack of genuine commitment to learning and growth within the show's production and management.
Hypothetical Learning and Growth Scenario
What if, instead of removing Chris Harrison, the franchise had allowed him to stay and publicly learn and grow from his mistakes? By focusing on his education and transformation, the franchise could have demonstrated a commitment to systemic change rather than superficial fixes. As James Baldwin famously said, "Not everything that is faced can be changed, but nothing can be changed until it is faced." Racism is a systemic issue, and addressing it requires more than just firing one person; it necessitates a comprehensive approach to dismantling the structures that perpetuate it.
Connecting to Workplace Dynamics
This scenario is not unique to the entertainment industry; it resonates deeply within workplace dynamics. Companies often respond to oppressive behaviour by firing individuals, viewing it as a quick fix. However, this approach does not address the root causes of the behaviour or contribute to a culture of learning and growth. Instead, workplaces should create environments where mistakes are education opportunities, and individuals are supported in their journeys toward understanding and inclusivity. This shift from punishment to growth can lead to more meaningful and lasting organizational change.
Strategies for Addressing Racist Behaviour in the Workplace
Implement Comprehensive DEI Training: Regular, mandatory Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion training for all employees, focusing on the impact of racism and ways to combat it.
Facilitate Open Dialogues: Create safe spaces for employees to discuss issues of race and racism, encouraging honest and respectful conversations.
Develop a Restorative Justice Program: Instead of punitive measures, use restorative justice practices to address racist behaviour, focusing on healing and understanding.
Mentorship Programs: Establish mentorship programs that pair employees from diverse backgrounds with leaders to foster mutual learning and support.
Create Clear Anti-Racism Policies: Draft and enforce policies that clearly outline the consequences of racist behaviour while emphasizing opportunities for education and improvement.
Support Employee Resource Groups (ERGs): Encourage the formation of ERGs focusing on racial diversity and inclusion, providing them with resources and support.
Offer Counseling and Support Services: Provide access to counselling and support services for employees affected by racism and those seeking to understand their biases.
Implement Bias Interrupters: Use specific strategies to identify and mitigate biases in hiring, promotion, and everyday workplace interactions.
Continuous Learning Opportunities: To keep the conversation on racism and inclusion active, offer ongoing education opportunities, such as workshops, seminars, and guest speakers.
Leadership Accountability: Ensure that leaders are held accountable for promoting and maintaining an inclusive workplace culture and for leading by example in their behaviour and decisions.
By adopting these strategies, companies can move beyond the surface-level responses of cancel culture and work towards creating a more inclusive and equitable workplace environment.